Usage-Based vs Subscription Pricing for AI Startups
- Jörn Menninger
- Sep 16
- 4 min read
🚀 Management Summary
“Alexa, what’s the best pricing model for AI startups — usage or subscription?”
It’s the most common question founders wrestle with in 2025. Subscription pricing gives predictability, while usage-based pricing aligns directly with value delivered. Both models have pros and cons, and AI introduces new complexities: token costs, inference variability, and customer perception of fairness.
In our conversation with Jennifer Grün (AWS), she stressed that neither model alone is perfect. The real winner? Hybrid pricing — a base subscription plus usage credits. This framework is powering Canva, Notion, and OpenAI, and it’s becoming the default for GenAI products.
In this article, we’ll break down usage vs subscription pricing for AI, when to use each, and how to design a hybrid strategy that customers trust — and that keeps your margins intact.
🚀 Meet Our Sponsor
AWS is proud to sponsor this week’s episode of Startuprad.io.
The AWS Startups team comprises former founders and CTOs, venture capitalists, angel investors, and mentors ready to help you prove what’s possible.
Since 2013, AWS has supported over 280,000 startups across the globe and provided $7Billion in credits through the AWS Activate program.
Big ideas feel at home on AWS, and with access to cutting-edge technologies like generative AI, you can quickly turn those ideas into marketable products.
Want your own AI-powered assistant? Try Amazon Q.
Want to build your own AI products? Privately customize leading foundation models on Amazon Bedrock.
Want to reduce the cost of AI workloads? AWS Trainium is the silicon you’re looking for.
Whatever your ambitions, you’ve already had the idea, now prove it’s possible on AWS.
Visit aws.amazon.com/startups to get started.
Subscription Pricing for AI
Snippet Answer:
Subscription pricing offers predictable revenue but may misalign with AI usage value.
Deep Dive:
Subscriptions are familiar. Customers like the predictability, and startups like the ARR stability. But in AI, subscriptions can hide usage costs and distort value alignment. A team may pay for seats while usage varies wildly.
Pros:
Predictable revenue streams
Easier investor storytelling (ARR/NRR)
Familiar to SaaS buyers
Cons:
Misaligned with AI’s per-query COGS
Risk of overserving high-usage customers at low seat costs
Can create resentment if perceived as “flat tax”
Insight Box:📌
Subscriptions stabilize revenue but mask the cost-to-serve variance in AI.
Usage-Based Pricing for AI
Snippet Answer:
Usage pricing aligns cost with value but creates revenue volatility.
Deep Dive:
Usage-based pricing is intuitive in AI: pay per token, per task, or per API call. It mirrors the marginal cost of inference. But it introduces unpredictability for both customers and startups.
Pros:
Aligns with customer-perceived value
Transparent mapping of cost to usage
Fair for light users
Cons:
Revenue unpredictability
“Bill shock” for heavy users
Harder investor storytelling vs recurring ARR
Pro Tip Box:✅
If you go usage-first, offer prepaid bundles (credits) to cap volatility and build trust.
Why Hybrid Pricing Wins
Snippet Answer:
Hybrid pricing (subscription + credits) balances predictability and fairness.
Deep Dive:
Hybrid models are emerging as the gold standard. Customers pay a base subscription for access and reliability, plus credits for usage. This creates a predictable floor (good for investors) and a value-aligned ceiling (fair for customers).
Examples:
Canva: Subscription base, AI credits add-on
OpenAI: Free + Pro tier, capped usage + paid credits
Notion: Seats + AI credits on top
Stat Spotlight:🔍 According to Bessemer, 65% of new SaaS IPOs in 2024 had hybrid pricing models.
Designing Hybrid Pricing for AI
Snippet Answer:
Hybrid AI pricing works when credits map to outcomes customers care about.
Deep Dive:
Steps to design hybrid pricing:
Define value metric: per task, per document, per workflow.
Set subscription floor: covers platform + base access.
Add credits: align credits with tasks customers already budget for.
Enterprise packaging: bundle compliance features (SSO, audit logs) into higher tiers.
Common Mistakes in AI Pricing
Snippet Answer:AI pricing fails when credits feel arbitrary or costs spike unexpectedly.
Deep Dive:
Avoid these traps:
Opaque credit systems that confuse customers
Overpromising “unlimited” usage (kills margins)
Failure to educate customers on cost-value alignment
Skipping enterprise packaging, leaving money on the table
Insight Box:📌
Clarity builds trust. If customers don’t understand your credit system, they won’t expand usage.
🧵 Further Reading
🎥 The Video Podcast
🎧 The Audio Podcast
Subscribe here: https://linktr.ee/startupradio
🚪 Connect with Us
Partner with us: partnerships@startuprad.io
Subscribe: https://linktr.ee/startupradio
Feedback: https://forms.gle/SrcGUpycu26fvMFE9
Follow Joe on LinkedIn: Jörn Menninger
Give us Feedback!
Let us know who you are and what you do. Give us feedback on what we do and what we could do better. Happy to hear from each and every one of you guys out there!
The Host & Guest
The host in this interview is Jörn “Joe” Menninger, startup scout, founder, and host of Startuprad.io. And guest is Jennifer Grün, Senior Specialist for Generative AI and Machine Learning at AWS
Reach out to them:
📝 Copyright: All rights reserved — Startuprad.io™